Market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is likely to replace the current flat 20 percent minimum upfront margin requirement for cash market trades with a risk-based framework that could lower margin requirements for investors in highly liquid stocks. The regulator has been discussing the proposal for quite a long time with stakeholders, and now the broader consultation is expected. As per sources, as the next step, the regulator is expected to come up with a consultation paper soon.
Risk-Based Upfront Margin CollectionThe proposal under consideration may require brokers to collect the lower of the applicable clearing corporation margin (Value at Risk plus Extreme Loss Margin) or 20 percent of the transaction value from clients before executing trades. The move is aimed at aligning the margin collected from investors with the actual risk assessed by clearing corporations and reduce unnecessary capital blockage.At present, brokers are mandated by clearing corporations to collect a minimum upfront margin of 20 percent from clients to avoid short collection penalties, even though the minimum margin levied by clearing corporations for many large-cap liquid stocks is around 12.5 percent, comprising 9 percent VaR and 3.5 percent ELM. View is this results in investors blocking more funds than actually required by the underlying market risk.The regulator's preliminary analysis with data of top 10 brokers suggests that the proposed move could reduce upfront margin requirements in the range of 10-15 percent for clients trading in highly liquid stocks without materially increasing risk. One source said, “The proposal was long under discussion with stakeholders and is nearly final”.
New Liquidity Criteria for Classification of StocksAlongside the margin review proposal, SEBI is also expected to tighten the criteria for classifying stocks based on liquidity. A working group comprising of clearing corporations had recommended to increase the trading frequency requirement for the most liquid Group I securities from the current 80 percent to 99 percent of trading days and reduce the impact cost threshold from 1 percent to 0.1 percent.Similarly, for the Group II securities, the trading frequency criteria was recommended more than 80 percent and 99 percent trading frequency or 0.1 percent impact cost.For Group III securities, the working group had suggested a trading frequency of less than 80 percent of trading days during the previous 6 months.The proposed classification will be significant for market participants because it would also determine eligibility for the Margin Trading Facility (MTF).Another source said, "The Working Group's recommended liquidity criteria for the grouping of securities are considered stringent and could shrink the universe of Group 1 stocks. It was therefore suggested that any revision should be implemented in a phased manner over a period of time, allowing the market sufficient time to adjust."The current criteria for classification of stocks for margining and MTF were introduced in 2005 and have not been majorly reviewed since then. Hence, the review is long overdue. The number of stocks for Group I stocks has expanded over time due to growth in the size of the market.Concentration Limits of StocksIn addition, the working group had also suggested introducing concentration limits on collateral accepted by clearing corporations and clearing members to reduce dependence on a single security. The Working Group had suggested to cap the clearing corporation-wise limit to 20 percent of non-promoter holding for F&O stocks and, for non- F&O stocks, the lower of 20 percent of the non-promoter holding or 3 times the average daily traded quantity in the last six months.For Clearing Member or clearing broker-wise, the limit prescribed by the panel was 50 percent of the average daily traded quantity in the last 6 months, including the proprietary securities and securities repledge on behalf of the broker, client or custodians.The Working Group had suggested that the limit would be computed and shared by clearing corporations at the start of the month. The existing collateral exceeding the proposed limits would be allowed a transition period to comply. For a 3-month period, the limit will be informed and not enforced in excess of the new limits.SEBI is considering a series of measures to deepen liquidity in the cash market as it seeks to boost trading volumes. The proposals under discussion include providing margin relief for buy-side trades through the Early Pay-In (EPI) facility, expanding the list of stocks eligible for short selling, and further strengthening the Stock Lending and Borrowing Mechanism (SLBM).SEBI did not respond to an email seeking comments on the proposal.
written by Brajesh Kumar
Source:moneycontrol

No comments:
Post a Comment